Sunday, November 21, 2021

How to build a successful vertical farm

How to Build a Successful Vertical Farm (Lessons from the Field)
Vertical Farming • Indoor Agriculture • Practical Lessons

How to Build a Successful Vertical Farm

The honest guide: why “warehouse + racks + LED lights” is not a business model, and what actually determines success — climate, lighting recipes, spacing strategy, and systems thinking.

The interest in growing plants indoors — in vertical farms, containers, or “plant factories” — keeps rising. And I understand why.

On paper, it sounds like the modern solution to land shortage, food security, and climate uncertainty: take an empty warehouse, stack shelves, plug in grow lights, grow lettuce all year round, and watch profits come in.

But many investors who entered this space with that assumption have been disappointed. Not because vertical farming is a bad idea — but because vertical farming is not a “plug-and-play” business. It is biology, physics, and operational discipline — packaged inside technology.

Core truth: You can have excellent packaging, attractive branding, and beautiful marketing… but the product itself — the consistency, taste, quality, and yield — will determine your success.

City farming expert Roel Janssen highlights a lesson many learn the hard way: new sensor technologies and the internet of things can elevate an indoor farm — but without a grower who truly understands how to grow plants indoors, you won’t get the best out of the operation.

Vertical farming is not a tech-first problem.
It’s a growing problem first, a technology problem second, and a business problem always.

Part 1: Getting the Climate, Lighting & Spacing Right

When you break down successful vertical farm projects, there are several key factors that repeatedly show up as “make or break” decisions. These are the areas that shape yields, quality, operating costs, and the ability to scale.

Key building blocks that determine success:

Crop selection Lighting selection & design-in Airflow design & climate control Spacing strategies Crop logistics & automation Irrigation & nutrition Data, sensors, control & software Substrate choice Target audience & sales channel

Now let’s talk business reality. When we look at return on investment (ROI) for a vertical farm, one metric quietly dictates profitability:

Grams per mol.
How many grams of crop you produce using the most ideal amount of light (measured in moles / mol). LEDs are among the largest expenses in infrastructure and operation — every wasted photon is wasted money.

Insights shared here are aligned with learnings from indoor farming research and commercial projects across regions (including work and testing environments like the Philips GrowWise Center and real farms across the US, Japan and Europe).

Step 1: Get the Climate Right (Or Nothing Else Works)

One area many new operators underestimate is climate. Indoor farming is not “set temperature once and forget it.” It is constant heat generation, constant humidity build-up, and constant airflow demands — especially at scale.

Here’s the uncomfortable physics of indoor farms: if we assume around 50% of electrical input becomes light, the remaining 50% becomes heat. That heat has to go somewhere.

A proper airflow can remove direct heat from lighting, but there is another hidden layer: once light is absorbed by the crop, it is indirectly converted into heat. The crop then evaporates water into the air to get rid of this heat — which raises humidity.

If humidity and temperature are not controlled, yields drop.
Poor climate control leads to uneven growth, stress responses, and extra costs later to “repair” inefficiencies that should have been designed correctly from day one.

That’s why a good ventilation and air handling system is not “nice to have.” It is the backbone of a working vertical farm.

Step 2: Get the Lighting Right (Not Just Brighter)

After climate is stable, the next question is: how do you maximize yield and quality with the light you pay for? This is where research and grower experience meet.

Many people think lighting is only about intensity. But in indoor farms, lighting is also about timing, spectrum, and crop-specific “light recipes.”

Take red oak lettuce. Outdoors, it turns red because it is stressed by sun exposure and temperature swings. That stress often comes with lower yield compared to green varieties.

Indoors, that same red oak lettuce may grow fast and strong — but remain mostly green because there is no UV stress. For the market, that appearance can be a problem because consumers expect it to look “red.”

The solution isn’t to grow slower or accept lower yield.
The solution is to apply a targeted pre-harvest light recipe that triggers coloration in just a few days.

This is why top farms treat lighting like strategy, not hardware: grow for biomass during the cycle, then apply a pre-harvest treatment for appearance and differentiation.

And once you layer this with better genetics and collaboration with breeders, farms can differentiate on taste, quality, shelf life, and colour — instead of competing only on price.

Step 3: Get the Spacing Right (Light the Plant, Not the Shelf)

Spacing is one of those topics that looks simple — until you calculate what wasted light costs you every month.

Your goal is to space plants so that each one receives an optimal amount of light, and you are lighting leaves, not empty areas or the shelves themselves.

Better spacing improves grams per mol.
It helps avoid waste, improves uniformity, and increases yield without necessarily increasing energy input.

Spacing strategy also affects automation decisions. Many operators jump straight to spacing robots because it sounds efficient. But smart farms do the math first: compare the additional yield gained from spacing against the cost of automation.

Sometimes manual spacing with a disciplined SOP is more cost-efficient. Sometimes automation is worth it. But either way, the decision should be based on data, not hype.

The Bigger Lesson: Vertical Farming Is Systems Thinking

Vertical farming is not a “technology stack.” It is a living system. A chain. And a chain is only as strong as the weakest link.

The best operators start with the plant, then design the environment, then layer in technology to support consistency. They respect the fact that you can’t negotiate with biology.

Success isn’t “how fast can we build?”
Success is “do we truly understand what the plant needs — and can we deliver it consistently at scale?”

Vertical farming done right can be one of the most precise and scalable ways to grow food in a changing world. But it requires patience, proper planning, and a team that understands growing, operations, and markets — not just machinery and dashboards.

So Let Me Ask You…

If you’ve been thinking about hydroponics or vertical farming — whether as a business, an education program, or even a personal project — these are the real questions that matter:

  • How will you start — small, controlled, and proven… or big, expensive, and risky?
  • Where can you start — at home, in a classroom, in a container, or with a pilot farm?
  • What crop will you start with — and do you understand its climate and light requirements?
  • Do you have a real grower on your team — or only technology and equipment vendors?
  • Do you know your customer — restaurants, retailers, schools, or direct-to-consumer?
  • Are you ready to treat this as a system — not a simple “buy and plug in” project?
  • Most importantly: are you ready to learn, test, adjust, and build discipline into the operation?

Because vertical farming rewards those who respect the process. The question is not whether vertical farming works. The real question is: are you prepared to make it work?

If you’d like, I can also turn this into a series: Part 2 (Operations & SOP), Part 3 (Business model & sales), and Part 4 (Education program for kids & adults).

Essential Indoor Growing Tips

What Is Needed for Effective Indoor Agriculture? (3 Pillars for Success)
Indoor Farming • Hydroponics • Urban Agriculture

What Is Needed for Effective Indoor Agriculture?

A well-designed indoor growing system is not magic. It is discipline, consistency, and a few core principles done right. Here are the three pillars that decide whether your indoor farm thrives — or quietly struggles.

Indoor agriculture is exciting because it promises something that outdoor farming cannot always guarantee: control. Control over climate. Control over light. Control over pests. Control over consistency.

But here’s the truth many people only learn after spending money: plants forgive mistakes outdoors because nature absorbs the shock. Indoors, the system exposes every weakness — airflow, humidity, spacing, light intensity, expectations, and discipline.

Indoor farming is not “set and forget.”
It’s “design it right, then run it consistently.”

A strong indoor growing setup always comes back to three core components:

Expert Lighting Controlled Atmosphere Growing Space

Pillar 1: Expert Lighting

In indoor agriculture, light is not just illumination. Light is food. The way you deliver light determines crop productivity, plant health, and how consistent your harvest becomes.

Why it matters: Good lights help manage plant transpiration, canopy saturation, and yield. If you’re chasing maximum yield, lighting is the first pillar you cannot compromise on.

And this isn’t only about “bright.” It’s about uniformity, stability, and matching the intensity to what the plant can actually use. Too little light gives weak growth. Too much light without the right environment can stress or burn plants.

Pillar 2: Controlled Atmosphere

A controlled environment is one that reduces external influence and keeps conditions stable. That means controlling temperature, humidity, airflow, and even how air is circulated or recirculated.

Why is this powerful? Because plants respond best to consistency. If your farm constantly pulls outside air, your system becomes a daily battle — heating, cooling, dehumidifying, adjusting, repeating.

Consistency = lower stress = better growth.
A stable environment helps keep bugs out, keeps humidity where it should be, and avoids unnecessary energy spikes from constant fluctuation.

The goal is simple: give plants exactly what they need — not what the weather decides to give them that day.

Pillar 3: Growing Space

People underestimate space — especially in tight environments like shipping containers. The temptation is to squeeze in more plants and assume it increases output.

But the reality is: when things get too tight, airflow suffers, humidity pockets form, and mold/mildew risks rise. You also lose flexibility — you can’t run high-intensity lighting if plants are too close to the fixtures.

Space is king.
The extra bit of space often improves airflow, dehumidification, and overall plant health — which leads to higher net yield and fewer headaches.

So… What Are the Best Indoor Grow Lights?

The best indoor grow light depends on your purpose: are you learning and experimenting at home, running an education project, or aiming for commercial production?

For beginners at home (small budget, high learning)

If you’re just getting started, the best solution is usually the one within your budget — because if it’s too expensive, you simply won’t start.

A simple T5 or T8 fluorescent can work for learning. It may not create “grocery store” lettuce, but it gives you the most valuable outcome at the beginning: experience.

LED vs Fluorescent (a practical safety angle)

One often ignored factor: children and pets. Fluorescent tubes can break and many contain mercury components, which makes them hazardous if damaged. LEDs are generally more durable, safer in classrooms and homes, and often more efficient — though typically higher in upfront cost.

How to Select a Crop for Indoor Growing

Start with something you actually enjoy eating. There’s no point growing mint if you can’t stand it — you’ll lose motivation fast.

Then be realistic about two things: the plant’s footprint (size) and lifecycle (how long to harvest). Some crops simply don’t make sense in small indoor setups.

Beginner-friendly crops: loose-leaf lettuces, herbs, many brassicas.
Harder at the start: fruiting plants like cucumbers, tomatoes, strawberries (flowering + vines + extra management).

Most people get discouraged not because indoor farming “doesn’t work,” but because they compare a home setup to industrial farms on social media and expect the same results immediately. Start small, learn the plant, then scale.

Can Indoor Farming Be Profitable?

Indoor farming can be profitable, but it is not instant. Many successful systems target an ROI within 3–5 years, which is normal for new businesses. Be cautious of anyone promising “quick returns in year one.”

The biggest driver of profitability is not hype — it’s discipline in farming, clarity in market, and consistency in operations.

Something to Think About (and Act On)

If you’ve been watching videos, reading articles, or dreaming about indoor farming — pause for a moment. Not to overthink. To get honest with yourself.

  • Why do you want to start indoor growing — health, learning, business, or sustainability?
  • Are you ready to start small first, just to learn the plant and the system?
  • Where can you start from today — a corner in your kitchen, a balcony, a small rack, a classroom, a garage?
  • What’s your first crop — something you love eating, or something you chose because it looks good online?
  • Do you have realistic expectations — or are you comparing your home setup to a commercial plant factory?
  • What will you control first: light, airflow, humidity — or will you “wing it” and hope it works?
  • If it’s for business: who will buy it from you, and why would they pay for your story and your quality?
  • And the biggest one: are you ready to be consistent? Because plants respond to consistency more than motivation.

My advice is simple: get started.
Start small. Learn fast. Improve one thing at a time.
Indoor agriculture is not about perfection — it’s about building a system that gets better every week.

Want me to turn this into a beginner step-by-step “Start Today” guide (with a simple home setup, basic costs, and a 14-day learning plan)? Tell me your target audience: kids, adults, schools, or business starters.

Vertical Farming for the Future

Indoor vertical farming
Indoor and vertical farming may be part of the solution to rising demands for food and limited natural resources. Photo credit: Oasis Biotech

Imagine walking into your local grocery store on a frigid January day to pick up freshly harvested lettuce, fragrant basil, juicy sweet strawberries, and ripe red tomatoes – all of which were harvested at a local farm only hours before you’d arrived. You might be imagining buying that fresh produce from vertical farms where farmers can grow indoors year-round by controlling light, temperature, water, and oftentimes carbon dioxide levels as well. Generally, fresh produce grown in vertical farms travels only a few miles to reach grocery store shelves compared to conventional produce, which can travel thousands of miles by truck or plane.

Beyond providing fresh local produce, vertical agriculture could help increase food production and expand agricultural operations as the world’s population is projected to exceed 9 billion by 2050. And by that same year, two out of every three people are expected to live in urban areas. Producing fresh greens and vegetables close to these growing urban populations could help meet growing global food demands in an environmentally responsible and sustainable way by reducing distribution chains to offer lower emissions, providing higher-nutrient produce, and drastically reducing water usage and runoff.

Recently, USDA and the Department of Energy held a stakeholder workshop focused on vertical agriculture and sustainable urban ecosystems. At this workshop, field experts shared thought-provoking presentations followed by small group discussions focusing on areas such as plant breeding, pest management, and engineering. Workshop attendees from public and private sectors worked together to identify the challenges, needs, and opportunities for vertical farming. A report on this workshop will be released to help inform Departmental strategic planning efforts for internal research priorities at USDA and external funding opportunities for stakeholders and researchers.

We’re excited about the potential opportunities vertical agriculture presents to address food security. 

Urban Farming: Growing Vegetables in Cities

 Sharing this article from https://www.bayer.com/en/news-stories/urban-farming-growing-vegetables-in-cities


Empty shelves, lines of shoppers waiting to get into grocery stores, worried people panic-buying – scenes from the novel coronavirus pandemic have suddenly made us aware of how fragile the supply chains for everyday items that we assumed were secure can be in times of crisis. In order to feed the world in the future, there need to be new solutions for farming. One such solution is urban farming.

More people, less arable land

Some numbers demonstrate the topicality of these deliberations: The United Nations estimates that there will be approximately 10 billion people on our planet by the year 2050, with some two-thirds living in cities. The world’s arable land per-capita is likely to shrink by 20 percent over that same period, due in part to increasing climate change and advancing erosion.

 

Innovative solutions are needed for feeding more people while using less land. Urban farming – particularly vertical farming – is one such solution.

 

vertical_farming_galerie_02.jpg

 

Rooftop vegetables

This cultivation method offers a whole range of advantages: In fact, a single vertical farm can grow 4 hectares (10 acres) — or roughly five Olympic-size swimming pools — worth of food on less than half a hectare of land, making it ideal for urban areas and in preserving space for biodiversity (by relieving pressure on natural fallow land that otherwise would be turned into farmland, thereby aiding wildlife conservation).
Vertical Farming also helps to meet the increasing need and desire for locally-grown produce. Local production eliminates long-distance transportation from producer to consumer, while also reducing food loss along the journey and food waste.
Tomatoes, peppers, lettuce, and mushrooms : These crops thrive in the controlled microclimates of the fields on each floor - free of the harsh extremes of climate change and seasonality. Correspondingly, these urban farms promise higher yields. At the same time, these self-contained, precision growing systems protect the exterior environment by reducing dependency on synthetic chemistry and other crop inputs, optimizing water use and allowing food growth in challenging environments with limited arable land. And of course, the benefits don’t end there.

 

  1. Frost can’t bite
    so farmers can grow their crops year-round.

  2. Pests can't pester
    so farmers can dramatically reduce inputs.

  3. Nutrients stay put
    so farmers can conserve natural resources.

  4. Moisture is recycled
    so farmers can use virtually every single drop to increase water efficiency by up to 90%.

  5. Land is (barely) needed
    so farmers can grow enough with less.

 

vertical_farming_galerie_04.jpg

 

Technologies make a significant difference in vertical farms

New sensors, smart energy systems, and other technologies make growing more efficient. Just like the many people using smart devices and automation to make their homes more convenient, vertical farms are typically automated to control light, temperature, and water use. They allow farmers to optimize the conditions required for growing to produce the food that consumers want most at the store.

 

AI and machine learning help to bolster efficiencies, save resources, and reduce the cost of growing crops vertically. Some systems can even use cameras and sensors to assess when crops are ready for harvest. Identifying exactly when to pick specific plants, this process has already been shown to significantly reduce the food waste that sometimes comes with full-field harvests.

 

vertical_farming_galerie_03.jpg

 

Even subtle innovations like advanced LED bulbs are helping to cut costs, increasing energy efficiency while drastically reducing heat waste within the system. Taken together, vertical indoor farms and automated technologies are producing a 100-fold increase in efficiency to generate 10 times the harvest while using only one-tenth of the resources.

 

However, no metropolis will be able to feed itself solely from urban farming. A 2018 study suggests that cities will most likely be able to produce enough vegetables for their population. In any case, experts anticipate increasing yields in the near future.

 

There are currently 204,387 sq m (about 2.2 million sq ft) of indoor farms operating across the globe, and that number is expected to increase almost tenfold to 2 million sq m (about 22 million sq ft) in the next five years.

 

Will vertical farming replace other farming environments? No, but as climate change and a growing global population continue to raise the stakes for our food system, vertical farming is emerging as one of many complementary solutions in our collective pursuit of sustainability and food security.

 

vertical_farming_galerie_01.jpg

 

Bayer unveils new company focused on developing breakthroughs in vertical farming

Leaps by Bayer and Singapore-based Temasek have already joined together to form the startup Unfold. The new venture will focus on innovation in vegetable varieties tailored for the unique indoor environment of vertical farms that deliver optimized quality and sensory experience.


Jürgen Eckhardt

Head of Leaps by Bayer

Companies like Unfold hope to supply restaurants, airlines, schools, hospitals, businesses, grocery stores, and on-line delivery services — both in city centers and throughout food deserts and especially in times of crisis such as the COVID-19 pandemic — with fresh, sustainable, and hyper-local produce with a smaller ecological footprint.

 

The formation of the new company Unfold aligns with our vision of “Health for All, Hunger for None”, a commitment to the Sustainable Development Goals the United Nations has set for 2030, especially the goals of assuring healthy lifestyles and putting an end to hunger.